KUALA LUMPUR: The High Court here today directed former Klang Member of Parliament Charles Anthony Santiago to make an apology to independent preacher Dr Zakir Naik over his statements linked to the 'Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) in 2019.
Judge Datuk Akhtar Tahir directed Santiago to do so after finding that he was liable for defaming Zakir.
In his judgement, Judge Akhtar ruled that the second statement made by Santiago in a lecture titled 'Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) on Nov 25, 2019, where Zakir had alleged that Santiago's statement had defamed him, was a dual prong, despite it being attributed to Zakir.
"One directed towards the Malaysian police and the Government, and at the other directed towards the plaintiff.
"The implication that can be derived from the remark against the plaintiff is that he had an influence over the police and the Government in the arrest of the two DAP members," he said.
The judge ruled that despite the court finding the remarks are an expression of Santiago's opinion, however, it is speculative in nature, and found to be defamatory against Zakir.
"The court also noted that the remark, instead of tarnishing the image and reputation of the plaintiff, has in fact enhanced the reputation of the plaintiff as being someone who is influential in Malaysia.
"The court, therefore, rules that the plaintiff is not entitled to any damages, but as the statement is defamatory, the court directs the defendant to apologise publicly for the remarks made linking the plaintiffs to the arrest of the two DAP members," said the judge.
Meanwhile, on Santiago's first statement made publicly towards Zakir for his talk in Kota Bharu, Kelantan on Aug 8, 2019, the judge ruled that it was not defamatory and did not tarnish Zakir's reputation.
Zakir, in the talk, reportedly delivered sensitive remarks that touched on the Malaysian Chinese and Indians where Zakir said the former were 'old guests' who should go back to their ancestral land, and the latter were more loyal to India's prime minister rather than Malaysia's prime minister.
Santiago, on August 13, 2019, issued a statement saying that the talk had the potential to cause racial riots as well as bitterness amongst Malaysians.
Judge Akhtar ruled that the press statement made by Santiago was indeed directed towards the plaintiff.
"In listening to the plaintiff's talk, the court noted that the plaintiff also made remarks about the Malaysian Chinese. It was clear that the plaintiff had interposed his personal grievance of being asked to leave the country by making these unnecessary remarks that the Malaysian Chinese should also be asked to leave the country.
"The court agreed with the defendant's press statement that the plaintiff's remarks can cause a threat to multiracial Malaysia. In fact, the court noted that the plaintiff's remarks had attracted a rebuke from the Malaysian Prime Minister and many other politicians.
"It is therefore the court's decision in this case that the defendant's first statement is not defamatory and in fact a statement which is justified and a fair statement," the judge ruled.
-- BERNAMA
Bernama
Mon May 22 2023
Judge Datuk Akhtar Tahir directed Charles Santiago to do so after finding that he was liable for defaming Zakir Naik. - FACEBOOK/ Charles Santiago/BERNAMA
Cabut undi projek pastikan kontraktor G1-G4 dapat peluang - Nanta
Ia dapat memastikan kontraktor kelas berkenaan peluang untuk melibatkan diri dalam kerja-kerja pembaikan infrastruktur jalan Persekutuan.
Pelaksanaan mekanisma levi pelbagai peringkat (MLTM) dijangka bermula Januari 2025
Mekanisma levi pelbagai peringkat (MLTM) dijangka dilaksanakan pada Januari hadapan, selepas perinciannya dimuktamadkan dan diluluskan Jemaah Menteri, kata Menteri Sumber Manusia, Steven Sim.
Portal UP_TVET bertujuan untuk memudahkan proses permohonan
Saluran permohonan untuk mengikuti kursus Pendidikan dan Latihan Teknikal dan Vokasional (TVET) yang dahulunya mengelirukan kini dibuat melalui satu saluran tunggal iaitu menerusi portal Unit Pengambilan TVET atau singkatannya UP_TVET yang dibangunkan oleh Kementerian Sumber Manusia (KESUMA).
Menurut Timbalan Perdana Menteri, Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid Hamidi,penggunaan saluran tunggal UP_TVET yang fleksibel dengan mengambil kira keperluan pelbagai syarat masuk merupakan satu inisiatif untuk membuka ruang seluasnya kepada rakyat Malaysia untuk menyertai program TVET.
Menurut Timbalan Perdana Menteri, Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid Hamidi,penggunaan saluran tunggal UP_TVET yang fleksibel dengan mengambil kira keperluan pelbagai syarat masuk merupakan satu inisiatif untuk membuka ruang seluasnya kepada rakyat Malaysia untuk menyertai program TVET.
Kerajaan digesa bawa Mala pulang dari penjara Nepal
Kerajaan didesak untuk membawa pulang seorang rakyat Malaysia yang meringkuk di penjara Nepal atas kesalahan Imigresen.
Jemaah lega dapat luah perasaan di Ranting Hati
Jemaah haji Malaysia melahirkan rasa lega kerana berpeluang meluahkan perasaan sejak tiba di Tanah Suci menerusi tulisan terapi naratif yang menghasilkan Ranting Hati, satu inisiatif terbaharu diperkenalkan oleh Unit Kaunseling Tabung Haji (TH) sebagai platform menangani cabaran sebagai tetamu Allah sepanjang operasi musim ini.
Proses penggapungan kapal ambil masa 21 jam
Kapal berdaftar di Singapura, Dali yang melanggar struktur Jambatan Francis Scott Key di Baltimore, Maryland yang kemudiannya runtuh, mempunyai klasifikasi yang sah dan sijil berkanun yang meliputi integriti struktur kapal dan fungsi peralatannya. Penguasa Maritim dan Pelabuhan Singapura (MPA) berkata kapal kargo itu juga telah menjalani dua pemeriksaan yang diluluskan oleh dua pelabuhan asing pada Jun dan September 2023 dengan klasifikasi dan tinjauan berkanun seterusnya dijangka pada Jun 2024.
Iran berkabung tiga hari
Iran memulakan tempoh berkabung tiga hari susulan kematian Presidennya, Ebrahim Raisi yang terlibat dalam nahas helikopter pada Ahad yang turut mengorbankan Menteri Luarnya Hossein Amirabdollahian.Rakyatnya menyatakan kesedihan terhadap pemergian pemimpin mereka yang dikatakan berjasa dalam memelihara tembok keselamatan negara dari peperangan di rantau bergolak itu.
Ebrahim Raisi, Hossein Amir-Abdollahian individu penting perjuang isu Palestin
Presiden Iran, Ebrahim Raisi dan menteri luarnya, Hossein Amir-Abdollahian disifatkan sebagai antara individu penting dalam usaha masyarakat antarabangsa memperjuangkan isu Palestin.
Kerajaan jamin bawa pulang pegawai perubatan terkandas di Rafah
Kerajaan memberi jaminan akan membawa pulang pegawai perubatan di bawah MERCY yang terkandas di Rafah, Gaza.
Israel sekal laluan darat, situasi bertambah buruk
Sekatan Israel ke atas laluan darat melumpuhkan kemasukkan bekalan kemanusian ke Gaza dan dijangka memburukkan lagi situasi semasa di Gaza.
Charles Santiago dilantik semula sebagai Pengerusi SPAN
Bekas Ahli Parlimen Klang Charles Anthony Santiago dilantik sebagai Pengerusi Suruhanjaya Perkhidmatan Air Negara (SPAN) berkuat kuasa 20 Mac lepas.